MLB The Show 25 review (PS5)

​MLB The Show 25 marks the 20th anniversary of the long-running baseball simulation series, delivering a comprehensive package that both honors its legacy and introduces a few thoughtful enhancements. Developed by San Diego Studio and published by Sony Interactive Entertainment, this installment continues to set the benchmark for baseball video games.​

One of the standout features is the expansion of the Road to The Show mode, now incorporating “The Amateur Years,” allowing players to experience games from high school through college. This addition offers a more immersive journey, enabling players to shape their athlete’s career from its inception. The revamped attribute progression system and customizable perks provide greater control over player development, catering to individual playstyles and preferences.​

In terms of gameplay mechanics, MLB The Show 25 introduces “Ambush Hitting,” a feature that lets batters anticipate pitch locations for potential performance boosts. While this adds a layer of strategy, the risk-reward balance may not appeal to all players, as misjudgments can lead to penalties and you never quite know if a CPU opponent is being fair about it. Additionally, the new G.O.A.T difficulty level offers a heightened challenge, pushing even seasoned players to refine their skills. However, newcomers might find this level daunting, potentially impacting accessibility.​

Franchise and March to October modes have undergone significant improvements, particularly in the Free Agency system. The introduction of risk-reward elements adds depth and realism to the pursuit of top free agents, enhancing strategic decision-making. Furthermore, enhancements to Player Valuation and Contract Logic contribute to a more authentic and engaging management experience.​

Visually, MLB The Show 25 shines on the PlayStation 5, boasting updated dirt and grass textures alongside real-time physics that elevate the overall realism. The attention to detail in stadiums and player animations immerses players in the game’s atmosphere. Complementing the visuals, the audio experience has been enriched with authentic high school and college locations and sounds, including the distinct clinks of metal bats and the ambient noise of chain-link fences. Enhanced stadium sounds and 3D crowd audio further contribute to the immersive environment.​

However, the game’s complexity and the plethora of features can be overwhelming for newcomers and casual baseball game fans. The extensive customization options and diverse gameplay mechanics, while appreciated by veterans, may pose a steep learning curve for those unfamiliar with the series. Despite efforts to introduce tutorials and guidance, the sheer depth of content might deter some players from fully engaging with all aspects of the game.​

In conclusion, MLB The Show 25 successfully balances honoring its rich history with introducing meaningful innovations. While it offers a deeply immersive and authentic baseball experience, the complexity and challenging new features may not cater to all audiences. Nonetheless, for dedicated fans and those willing to invest the time to master its intricacies, MLB The Show 25 stands as a testament to the series’ enduring excellence.

Score: 8.0/10

Leave a comment