Ghost of Yōtei: Echoes of Sekigahara review (PS5)

Expansions for established open-world games face a difficult balancing act: they need to offer a compelling reason to return without losing sight of what made the original experience enjoyable. Published by Sony and developed by Sucker Punch Productions, Ghost of Yōtei: Echoes of Sekigahara takes a relatively conservative approach, expanding Atsu’s story with a new region, additional activities and some welcome combat additions. Its biggest contribution, however, is a more personal chapter in the protagonist’s history, exploring events surrounding the Battle of Sekigahara and introducing someone who clearly left a lasting impression on her.

The story takes place during the events of the main campaign rather than after its conclusion, with players needing to have progressed sufficiently through the original adventure before accessing the expansion. Atsu is drawn to the Ashoro Foothills after learning that Nagato, a former companion from her days fighting at Sekigahara, has become the target of a bounty. Their reunion is hardly a straightforward affair, as the two share a complicated history that gradually unfolds through flashbacks. Nagato is an interesting addition to the cast, and the relationship between him and Atsu provides a welcome opportunity to explore a more vulnerable, romantic side of the otherwise hardened bounty hunter. The writing does a good job of balancing their shared past with the problems unfolding in the present, although certain developments could have benefited from clearer explanations. The decision to position the expansion within the main storyline also creates occasional narrative awkwardness, particularly when events and motivations don’t quite line up with what players already know about the campaign’s eventual outcome.

The new region is relatively small compared with the enormous world of the original game, but that works largely in its favor. The Ashoro Foothills are under the control of the Vipers, a faction previously associated with the Snake, whose death has left its members fighting over control. Their activities have devastated the surrounding countryside, with polluted waterways, depleted wildlife and frightened inhabitants giving the area a noticeably different atmosphere from the more picturesque locations elsewhere in Ezo. This environmental deterioration isn’t merely a visual gimmick, either, as restoring the region and helping its inhabitants become important parts of the experience. Optional quests are particularly enjoyable because they frequently provide additional insight into the local population and the Vipers’ activities rather than feeling like arbitrary distractions. New fox dens, bounties and other activities also make exploration worthwhile, although the limited size of the region means there isn’t quite as much territory to discover as in the base game.

Combat remains largely familiar, retaining the responsive swordplay, parrying and weapon-based counters that made the original game enjoyable. There are some useful additions, though, including heavy weapons such as clubs and kanabō that can be picked up and used to deliver powerful attacks before eventually breaking. Bolas provide another way to temporarily incapacitate enemies, while the ability to catch incoming arrows and send them back towards their attackers adds a satisfying defensive option. Players also need to pay attention to arrows lodged in Atsu, as these can interfere with her ability to use Spirit-related abilities until they are removed. The new mechanics fit naturally into the existing combat system, but they don’t fundamentally change how encounters work. The heavy weapons in particular feel more like temporary power-ups than fully developed additions to Atsu’s arsenal, and players looking for a substantial evolution of the original combat mechanics may be disappointed.

The expansion also introduces some additional challenges and opportunities to put these mechanics to use, including tougher enemy encounters and new duels. The Vipers bring a few variations to familiar enemy archetypes, although their presence doesn’t radically change the combat experience. Their traps also make stealth encounters slightly more interesting, preventing players from relying quite so heavily on familiar approaches to sneaking through vegetation. The controls remain essentially unchanged, which is largely a positive given how well the original game handled its combination of swordplay, ranged attacks and stealth. However, some of the underlying shortcomings remain as well, including occasional camera frustrations, unreliable lock-on behavior and enemy attacks that can be difficult to react to in time. These aren’t problems introduced specifically by the expansion, but they do carry over into its encounters.

One of the more substantial additions is Most Wanted, a new single-player roguelite mode built around successive waves of enemies, increasingly difficult encounters and eventual battles against members of the Yōtei Six. Players select from four characters: Atsu, Oyuki, Nagato and the returning Jin Sakai from Ghost of Tsushima. Each has their own abilities and combat characteristics, providing some welcome variety. Between waves, players can select upgrades and bonuses that influence their effectiveness during a run, while currency earned along the way can be invested in permanent unlocks such as weapons, techniques, charms and additional abilities. The prospect of gradually developing different characters and experimenting with combinations of upgrades provides a decent incentive to keep playing, and the combat-focused format is a good fit for players who simply want to spend more time fighting without having to explore the open world.

Unfortunately, Most Wanted doesn’t quite reach the potential of its premise. The basic structure is enjoyable, and the different characters offer enough variation to keep encounters interesting for a while, but the mode relies heavily on familiar enemy groups, arenas and boss encounters. There is little in the way of unexpected objectives or alternative challenges to break up the action, with stealth largely absent from a mode that could have benefited from a more varied approach. Progression can also feel somewhat slow, particularly because so many of the abilities and techniques available in the main game need to be unlocked again. The difficulty balance is occasionally uneven, and some characters can make certain encounters considerably easier than others. Most Wanted is therefore a worthwhile extra for anyone who enjoys Yōtei’s combat, but it feels more like an enjoyable extension of an existing formula than a particularly ambitious new mode.

Visually, Echoes of Sekigahara maintains the impressive presentation of the original game, although the Ashoro Foothills deliberately take a different approach to the landscapes players may remember. The polluted rivers, lifeless surroundings and gloomy atmosphere create a convincing sense of a region suffering under the Vipers’ influence. As Atsu helps its inhabitants and the land gradually begins to recover, the changing environment reinforces the expansion’s central themes. There are still plenty of beautiful vistas and memorable locations, and Sucker Punch once again demonstrates an excellent understanding of how to make its world inviting to explore. Character animations and cinematic presentation are generally strong as well, although transitions between cutscenes and gameplay can occasionally look awkward. The audio and overall atmosphere continue the established approach of the base game, helping the new area feel like a natural part of the larger adventure.

With around five to eight hours of story and exploration, depending on how much optional content players tackle, Echoes of Sekigahara isn’t an especially lengthy expansion. Most Wanted considerably extends that offering, particularly for those interested in unlocking everything and improving their performance across its different challenges. There are also plenty of additional cosmetic rewards, including new armor sets and equipment, with some particularly appealing designs. These extras provide further incentives to explore the new region and complete its activities, although they won’t necessarily be enough to persuade everyone to spend considerable time with the roguelite mode.

Ghost of Yōtei: Echoes of Sekigahara is a worthwhile return to Ezo, primarily because of its engaging new storyline and the way it expands on Atsu’s character. Nagato is a welcome addition, the Ashoro Foothills offer a distinctive setting, and the optional activities are generally more thoughtfully integrated into the world than the usual open-world busywork. The combat additions are enjoyable but relatively modest, while Most Wanted provides some extra replay value without doing anything particularly innovative. Those hoping for an expansion as transformative as Iki Island may find the overall package somewhat conservative, but there is enough quality content here to justify another journey alongside Atsu. Its strongest moments come from exploring the consequences of the past rather than reinventing the gameplay, and that proves to be a perfectly good reason to return.

Score: 8.5/10

Leave a Reply