Party games are at their best when they give friends an excuse to laugh at and with each other, and Fakin’ It XL has a particularly entertaining way of doing that. Developed and published by Jackbox Games, this standalone version revisits one of the developer’s more successful social deduction games, giving it additional content, new ways to play and, perhaps most importantly, the option to bring together friends who aren’t physically in the same room. The concept remains wonderfully simple: everyone receives a question or instruction on their phone, except for one unfortunate participant, the Faker, who must pretend to know what’s going on. What follows is a combination of bluffing, interrogation and increasingly ridiculous accusations.
The basic premise is easy to understand. Players receive instructions on their personal devices and respond by performing an action, such as raising a hand, holding up a certain number of fingers, giving a thumbs-up or pointing at another participant. The catch is that the Faker either receives no prompt or gets a slightly different one, forcing them to improvise and hope their response doesn’t attract too much attention. Once everyone’s answers have been revealed, the group discusses the suspicious behavior and votes on who they believe is bluffing. The Faker has to survive multiple rounds of questioning, while the other participants attempt to expose them. It’s a straightforward formula, but one that creates plenty of opportunities for hilarious misunderstandings and wonderfully unconvincing explanations.
What makes the experience particularly enjoyable is that success depends as much on knowing the other participants as it does on interpreting their answers. Someone might give an apparently innocent response that suddenly becomes suspicious when everyone starts questioning their reasoning. Meanwhile, the Faker can exploit personal knowledge, deliberately steer conversations in another direction or simply try to look confident enough to avoid scrutiny. This creates a surprisingly engaging social dynamic in which the actual questions are sometimes less important than the conversations they provoke. The different round types also help prevent the experience from becoming too predictable. Alongside familiar hand-raising and pointing challenges, Thumb Luck introduces thumbs-up and thumbs-down responses, while Emojional Damage lets players communicate through emojis. Number Pressure adds another straightforward way to participate, and the final Text You Up round challenges everyone to answer several questions, with the Faker receiving slightly different prompts. These additions provide some welcome variety, although the relatively limited number of categories and occasional generic questions can make repeated sessions feel somewhat familiar.
The biggest improvement over the original experience is arguably the introduction of dedicated remote play. Previously, Fakin’ It was largely dependent on everyone being physically present, since much of its humor came from observing other people’s gestures and reactions. Fakin’ It XL offers an alternative that adapts certain rounds for online sessions, allowing participants to join through a browser on their phone, tablet or another internet-connected device. Actions that would normally involve pointing at someone or making a physical gesture are translated into on-screen responses, making the game considerably more practical for groups spread across different locations. Only the host needs to own the game, which also makes it relatively easy to organize a session. Nevertheless, remote play cannot completely recreate the experience of watching friends hesitate, change their answers or struggle to maintain a convincing poker face in person. Players will also need a separate voice or video call to communicate, as the game itself doesn’t provide the social interaction that makes the experience work so well.
The controls are appropriately uncomplicated, with players using their own mobile devices rather than needing to pass around a traditional controller. This makes joining a session accessible, while the host takes care of the main game through the PlayStation 5. Setting up a room is straightforward, and the available options provide a reasonable degree of flexibility. These include content filters, profanity settings, subtitles, adjustable timers and audience participation, alongside options for password protection and controlling who can start the game. There is, however, a small learning curve when it comes to understanding some of the individual round rules. The introductory instructions don’t always explain every detail particularly well, and a practical example before starting would have made the initial experience more welcoming. Once everyone understands what is expected, though, the mechanics are simple enough that the game rarely gets in the way of the fun.
Visually, Fakin’ It XL takes a functional approach rather than trying to turn its relatively simple concept into something unnecessarily elaborate. The presentation revolves around displaying questions, responses, player avatars and voting information clearly, keeping the focus on the participants rather than the screen. The expanded avatar selection provides a little extra personality, while the adaptations for remote play make it easier to follow everyone’s responses without needing to see their actual gestures. The audio is similarly unobtrusive, with an elevator-music-style theme providing some background entertainment in the menus. Neither the visuals nor the soundtrack are particularly remarkable, but that’s hardly the main attraction here. The real entertainment comes from the people playing, and the presentation does a sufficient job of supporting that experience.
There are a few limitations worth considering before inviting everyone over for a session. The game requires at least three participants, and there are no computer-controlled opponents or matchmaking options for anyone struggling to assemble a group. This means its appeal depends almost entirely on having friends or family members willing to participate. That’s not necessarily a problem for a party game, but the interrogation mechanics also require people to be comfortable defending their answers and accusing others. Groups that are reluctant to engage in that kind of playful confrontation might not get quite as much out of it. Furthermore, the relatively small selection of question categories can eventually become noticeable, particularly when prompts start repeating or feel too vague to make identifying the Faker especially challenging. These shortcomings don’t ruin the experience, but they do limit its long-term variety.
Fakin’ It XL is therefore a welcome return for one of Jackbox Games’ more entertaining party concepts, even if the standalone release doesn’t necessarily feel substantial enough to justify itself for everyone. The additional round types and larger player capacity provide some worthwhile improvements, while remote play makes it considerably easier to organize sessions with friends who cannot meet in person. However, the underlying experience remains very much the same, and the limited variety of prompts and dependence on an enthusiastic group mean that its appeal will vary considerably between players. For existing fans, there’s plenty of familiar fun here, and newcomers get an accessible introduction to social deduction without complicated rules or demanding gameplay. Just make sure everyone is prepared to lie, accuse and defend themselves, because the most convincing Faker might be sitting right next to you.
Score: 7.8/10

